Baker On The Square
Baker
On The Square
Checking hours… …

Milan & Norwalk, Ohio · Est. March 2022

Mixed, proofed and baked this morning.

Everything from scratch, every morning, in the 1900 storefront on Milan's village square. Cheesecake by the slice, bread by the loaf, and a pastry case that's never quite the same twice.

See the menu Order delivery Call (567) 401-6120
Hours
Tue–Fri 7–2 · Sat 8–2
Closed Sunday & Monday
Find us
Milan & Norwalk
Both locations
Orders
4–5 days ahead
Cakes, cheesecakes, trays
BAKER ON THE SQUARE EST. 1900 BAKER ON THE SQUARE MILAN · OHIO · 44846 2022 FROM SCRATCH

CHEESECAKE

Nineteen flavors, all baked here

Creamy, yet firm, with a subtle hint of sweetness. Nineteen flavors, classic with a topping through to Biscoff cookie butter.

$8 a slice $48–54 whole Whole cakes ordered ahead

PASTRY CASE

Different every morning

Thirty-plus in rotation: cinnamon rolls, scones, turnovers, savory twists.

BREAKFAST · UNTIL 2

Made on our own bread

Bacon or sausage with egg and cheese, on a croissant, bagel or sourdough.

On right now

What we're baking this season

Full menu

Whole black forest cake, chocolate glaze and cherries on top
01 · Black forest cake
A tray of chocolate chip cookies
02 · Chocolate chip cookies
A slice of cheesecake with cherry topping
03 · Cheesecake by the slice
Buckeye brownies with peanut butter and chocolate
04 · Buckeye brownies

Custom orders

Weddings, birthdays, and the Tuesday you just need four dozen cupcakes

Custom cakes, cheesecakes and large cookie and cupcake orders are all done in house. Call or email with your date and what you have in mind and we'll work it out from there.

4–5 days' notice on every order. Everything is baked to order, so give us most of a week. More for weddings and large events.

Call (567) 401-6120 Contact@BakerOnTheSquare.com
  • 01Whole cheesecakes, $48, any of our flavors.
  • 02Cheesecake-cakes, $48, carrot, red velvet or strawberry shortcake.
  • 03Cupcakes, four dozen or more takes 15% off.
  • 04Cookies, deluxe by the dozen for parties and trays.
  • 05Wedding & celebration cakes, call to talk through the design.

Open since March 2022

Richard and Amy Shafer, back in a building his family used to run.

They bought the 1900 storefront at 47 Front St in 2021 and spent nine months putting it back together before opening the doors. Everything's been mixed and baked in this building ever since.

Visit

Two shops

Norwalk Location

Donuts in place of the pastry case, and open early seven days a week.

Where
171 Milan Ave
Norwalk, Ohio 44857
Hours
Mon–Sat 6–6 · Sun 8–4
Open seven days
See the menuDirections(567) 424-6333